Tierney (un)Truth and (not) Dare

Posted by – June 18, 2010

A little more than a week ago, John Tierney published an article in the NYT “daring” to question whether or not girls just aren’t good at math. What a goddamn revelation. I don’t know what we would do without such daring journalism.

Maggie Koerth-Baker over at BoingBoing actually interviewed some female scientists on the topic. One of them, a Dr. Isis, had some great things to say:

John Tierney titles his article “Daring to Discuss Women’s Potential in Science,” as though he is bravely daring to out the dirty little secret that we all supposedly know deep in our hearts. Girls suck at math and science. The truth is, they really don’t. It’s just that John Tierney sucks at googling.

I love the idea of John Tierney publishing pie recipes instead:

Yet, he clearly has ignored the fact that this phenomenon is unique to the United States. Indeed, in countries with more gender equal cultural norms, the divide disappears. In Iceland, girls out perform boys in math and science. Japanese girls out perform American boys. Maybe in his next column Tierney will argue some type of evolutionary difference between the boys and girls in these other countries and American boys and girls. Personally, I would find it much more interesting if he would start posting recipes for pies we could make with all the cherries he’s picking.

and then:

Can we all agree that Tierny pulled this completely out of his ass? Someone who scores in the top 99.9% of an aptitude test is more likely to get tenure than someone who scores in the top 99.1% in the seventh grade? Really?

Honestly, the NYT had no business publishing a poorly-researched and obviously biased article. Let’s all keep in mind that Tierney has already written in defense of Summers, which indicates some pre-existing bias — other than the obvious sexist one, of course.

These guys tire me.

1 Comment on Tierney (un)Truth and (not) Dare

  1. Catrina says:

    This one so frosts any sense of objective justice that it simply “must” be responded to. As a business operations professor, I have encountered numerous outstanding women mathematicians and operations professors that do great hard science research. There is plenty of math in the science of business operations. Grasping math has nothing to do with gender at all! Contending women are bad at science is ludicrous.

    I have not been on these blogs for quite some time. It is realized no one cares. However, I have started full transition. Monday I walk out of the house fully as Catrina. Unfortunately Stage Four cancer has gotten in the way. I have been forced off HRT because of the risk hormones might have on chemo treatments. My oncologist is worried about blood clots.

    So I might be the ugliest non passable TS person on the planet. But at least I will be comfortable in my own skin for the last period of this life.

    Best to all….. and I mean all…

    Catrina

Leave a Reply